It’s very hard not to admire this movie. It does so many things well. There are shots in it that are light years ahead of the rest of the horror field in 2026. The whole thing is just so much more atmospheric, flashy, and useful. There’s always something lurking in the background, or something that doesn’t belong, that will soon insert itself into the scene in a way that startles the audience. Everything from the creature design to the use of gore to the creativity of the ludicrous scenarios our protagonist finds himself in is mostly clever and crowd-pleasing.
Where this film goes awry for me is said protagonist. I have lamented plenty of times in reviewing horror films that what annoys me most about the genre is that most characters in big-budget American films (if not all of the characters in some of them) consistently make nonsensical choices that put their lives in danger ON PURPOSE, just so we, the audience, can get some horror movie shenanigans on screen when the story doesn’t even call for it. I am relatively certain that this feature-length film could have been a really interesting 30-minute television pilot if this character hadn’t kept making the worst possible decisions in the most dangerous scenarios ON PURPOSE.
I understand horror comedies tend to do stuff like this. SHAUN OF THE DEAD is a great example of a film where characters make idiotic decisions. But in that movie’s case, the characters are oblivious to their surroundings while they make those decisions… until they aren’t. Once they’re fully aware, they start making more educated choices.
This movie has a protagonist so extreme in his stupidity that he is utterly unlikable. He’s so unsurpassably unintelligent that I’m amazed he can drive a car, that he holds a job, and that he’s had any feasible relationship with another human being. There is such an absence of brainpower that I’m surprised he can speak in coherent sentences or walk in a straight line. He projects a transcendent unintelligence unlike that of any horror film character I’ve ever seen, and I’m not being hyperbolic about that. This is the worst. I shouldn’t be rooting for the zombies in a RESIDENT EVIL film, but my annoyance with this character’s intergalactic idiocy hit level 10 about 15 minutes in, and he only got worse as the film went along.
This movie goes to show that Zach Cregger truly deserves to be among the premier new-generation horror directors like Jordan Peele, Ari Aster, Mike Flanagan, and Robert Eggers. One could argue that this is as stylistically impressive as almost anything those directors have ever done, and it pays homage to an iconic franchise. There had to be more pressure on him to get this right than if he weren’t adapting a video game, and he pulls it off well enough.
I am an unabashed American horror film hater of the highest quality. Contrary to popular belief, if it isn’t from one of those directors, there are usually more bad things to say than good. As much as I absolutely hate this film’s main character, I do have to give credit where credit is due… it gets everything else right. There’s only so much a certified horror movie hater like me can say when almost everything is done this well.

Experience Whenever

