3 years after the marvelous release of HUNGER GAMES: BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES, we are back in Panem with a new addition to the HUNGER GAMES saga. This time our story recounts the devastating history of Haymitch Abernathy and his time in the second Quarter Quell. As a sequel to the 2023 film and a prequel to the 2012 trilogy we see Haymitch (Joseph Zada) as he deals with being reaped alongside 47 other tributes in the 50th annual Hunger Games. Fans get a great deal of recognizable characters that we love from the original series and a deeper look into their backstories. The film is directed by dystopian legend Francis Lawrence, known for his work on the past 4 HUNGER GAMES films as well as his magnum opus, which was last yearâs THE LONG WALK. With Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie working alongside author Suzanne Collins to adapt the novel, the film has a well-rounded creative team that sparked large amounts of excitement since it was announced. The film is the star of this Thanksgiving season and one of the most anticipated releases of the year.
The best part of the entire film is without a doubt the star-studded casting, all thanks to the work of casting directors Debra Zane and Dylan Jury. In a cast full of gems, there is one that shines brighter than the rest- Jesse Lon Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee. If I could only give one reason to see this, it is simply for the brilliant work he does here. It is the most faithful tribute that couldâve been paid to the late, great Philip Seymour Hoffman. Though his last film was highly controversial, Plemons simply gave it his all in DIGGER, and somehow he still had more to give here. His performance is thoughtful, intricate, and highly skilled. Jesse Plemons is playing chess and while the rest of the cast is ALSO playing chess, heâs just playing it better.
Plemons is not the only one to applaud in the film though. McKenna Grace as Maysilee Donner is emotionally charged and skillfully dialed in. Grace has been blessing our screens for 10+ years now and gets better with every project. She elevates every scene sheâs in and has dynamic chemistry with every character she interacts with. Ben Wang is a delight as always, reuniting with director Francis Lawrence after his memorable performance in THE LONG WALK. Ralph Fiennes puts his own spin on the role of President Snow, and while it might be different from the work Donald Sutherland or Tom Blythe did- that does not mean itâs bad. In fact, itâs quite the opposite. I found the energy completely shifted anytime he was on screen as he commands the attention of the audience through quiet and precise action. This is a Snow weâve never seen before, clearly still haunted by the thought of Lucy Gray Baird. Any scene that includes both Fiennes and Plemons is practically a masterclass in acting, a wonderful duo playing off of each other. The film also featured my favorite actor of all time, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman! Culkin is humorous and kills every second of screen time he has, probably because this role is his exact typecast. The man has found one type of character to play, but he does it so well (good enough to win an Oscar and completely sweep the 2025 award season!) that we canât complain. The world can always use more Culkin. Rounding out the rest of the cast is Glenn Close as the ruthless Drusilla Sickle, Maya Hawke and Lili Taylor as Wiress and Mags, respectively, Kelvin Harrison Jr. as Beetee Latier, and of course, Elle Fanning as the one and only Effie Trinket. All of them add so much depth to the cast and though they have few scenes, the film would be lacking without the talent they provide.
There is someone big that I have yet to mention⊠the man himself- Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy. Unfortunately, this brings me to issue one of the film. Zada does not come to the level needed to lead a HUNGER GAMES story, especially one as tragic as Haymitchâs. His accent is one of the worst to be heard, with some pronunciations that made me guffaw in the theater. When Kieran Culkin discussed finding the line between copying Stanley Tucci and making his own character, he said his biggest fear was mocking what Tucci did in the role of Caesar. It feels as if Zada is doing an impression of Woody Harrelson as Haymitch. There are some scenes in which he really reins it in and lives up to the role. Those few scenes are the best in the runtime. But apart from those brief emotional moments, I did not find him to be a character I was wholeheartedly rooting for. I want someone that I am totally invested in and unfortunately, Zada was just not that. You have to be at the top of your game to headline a film in this series, especially following in the footsteps of Jennifer Lawrence and Rachel Zegler. This performance simply falls short overall.
The second issue in the film is the lack of violence. After coming off the success of The Long Walk, which was one of the most graphically violent films Iâve ever seen in theaters- I expected more from Francis Lawrence. This is the first film in the series which, quite frankly, lacks any stakes. While watching the film I wondered if this was because this is the only time in the franchise where we know what happens before we even step into the theater (granted that youâve seen the predecessors in the series). There is a fine line that lies between glamorizing the brutality in these films and hiding it too much and minimizing the horror. Every other film has hit the mark perfectly and shows exactly what it needs to but never makes it too disturbing where it isolates audiences. But when you have a HUNGER GAMES film that does not properly highlight the charactersâ deaths⊠you are entirely losing the messages that make these films so powerful. The same way the Capitol hides what doesnât fit their narrative, I canât help but wonder if this film was made to be more âmarketableâ and mass-appealing. Are you able to sell HUNGER GAMES themed popcorn buckets and merchandise knowing that the film you are promoting is about the death of innocent children? And if you canât do both of those things⊠which one is more important to the studios?
The final glaring issue is the pacing. The 2 and a half hour runtime actually goes by quite fast and the film doesnât drag, if anything it rushes far too much. The first act is wonderfully assembled and laid out. Until we get to the second act and actually enter the arena. In a film about the Hunger Games, the games feel like one of the least important parts of the movie. Not only does it feel cast aside, it simply goes by too fast. Besides one great cinematic moment, the climax of the whole film is lackluster and messily constructed. Iâm sure that my issue with the minimal violence plays a part in why the games donât have the same effect as the previous films. Once you get to the games, it feels as if theyâre a side plot and not the main event the story is focused on. They spend so much time in the Capitol preparing that at some moments I forgot what we were actually here to watch. I wouldâve cut content from the training and instead spent that time in the games, focusing more on the characters and you know⊠the deaths inside the arena.
SUNRISE ON THE REAPING is simply not a coherent standalone story, it is one of that relies on the connection we hold to the world of Panem. Which is fine, but it can be draining to watch 2 1/2 hours of a story being spelled out for the audience. There is simply no subtlety and no risks being taken. The cast does a fantastic job of moving the story forward, yet they were not given a lot to work with. Which is such a shame when the book is so strong and has so much heart behind it- it simply didnât translate the same to the screen. For what itâs worth the film is entertaining and visually stunning. I loved the production design and use of color implemented throughout the film. However I wish it wouldâve leaned more into the reality of the story, both in the gravity of the situations at hand and more natural emotion. And while you canât include everything from the book, the moments they cut would have provided more to the overall story.
Perhaps my expectations were too high, but I canât help but feel a bit let down with the film overall. I had a decently enjoyable time and there is so much good to marvel at throughout the runtime. It is hard when the things that donât work impact the entirety of the film and therefore canât be ignored. The cast is one that will be talked about for years to come, and the design of the arena is one of the most visually stunning weâve ever seen. The character of Haymitch is harrowing and I am overjoyed that we finally got a chance to spotlight what he went through. If you are a fan of the series, I highly recommend watching it. It is far from a waste of time and a good theatrical experience, even if some elements do not measure up to the past films in the franchise.
THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING is now playing in theaters.

